• Energy
    • Wind Power
    • Hydroelectric
  • Self-Consumption
    • Wind
    • Photovoltaic Solar
    • Storage
    • Microgrids
    • Biogas
    • Hydrogen
  • TECHnPower
    • Wind Turbines
      • nED100
    • Energy Storage
      • Battery Energy Storage Systems
      • Power converters
  • Services
    • Decarbonization
    • Energy Engineering
    • EPC Energy
    • Operation & Maintenance
    • 24/7 Control Centre
    • Monitoring & Control
  • En
    • Es
    • Gl

< Back | 2 March 2020

Case study of complementary simulations of technical regulations

In the previous blog post we analysed the simulation programs currently most commonly used to carry out the complementary simulations described in the Technical Supervision Standard (NTS). These simulations make it possible to certify the compliance of a generation plant with the technical requirements of the grid connection code in Spain.

In this post we analyse, by means of a case study, each of the complementary simulations that a generation plant must carry out to certify compliance with the grid code.

Description of the power plant under study

A 40 MW wind farm connected to the transmission grid at a voltage level of 220 kV has been chosen as the study plant. The Grid Connection Point (RCP) is shared with other installations, so the requirements will be assessed at the Central Busbars (CB), instead of at the RCP, according to the indications of the NTS for the case of shared installations.

Technical requirements applicable to the generating plant

The wind farm under study is a type D plant, according to the significance defined in the NTS, as it is connected at a voltage level (220 kV) higher than 110 kV. Consequently, all the technical requirements described in the NTS will apply to it, as it is the most demanding type of plant (with the exception of the exclusive requirements for synchronous generation). Among the different applicable requirements, compliance with the following can be certified by carrying out the complementary simulations described in the NTS.

  • 5.1. Over-frequency limited power-frequency regulation mode (MRPFL-O)
  • 5.2. Underfrequency limited power-frequency regulation mode (MRPFL-U)
  • 5.3. Mode of power-frequency regulation (MRPF)
  • 5.7. Reactive power capability
  • 5.8. Reactive power control

For each of these five technical requirements, we analyse the complementary simulations below.

Over-frequency limited power-frequency regulation mode (MRPFL-O)

This simulation allows the dynamic response of the wind farm to significant increases in the grid frequency to be evaluated. To do this, a frequency sweep is carried out from 50 Hz to 51.4 Hz, as shown in the following figure, and it is checked that the power reductions of the wind farm and the stabilisation time comply with the ranges indicated in the standard.

Fig 1. Complementary simulation of the power-frequency regulation mode limited to overfrequency.

Underfrequency limited power-frequency regulation mode (MRPFL-U)

This simulation makes it possible to evaluate the dynamic response of the wind farm to significant drops in the grid frequency. To do this, a frequency sweep is carried out from 50 Hz to 48.4 Hz, as shown in the following figure, and it is checked that the power increases of the wind farm and the stabilisation time comply with the ranges indicated in the standard.

Fig 2. Complementary simulation of underfrequency limited power-frequency regulation mode

For both MRPFL-O and MRPFL-U modes, the results of the simulations show that the power values required by the standard are reached, but in a slightly longer time than required. We would therefore recommend adjusting the necessary parameters of the plant controller to speed up the response of the power-frequency control module, subject to the approval of the controller manufacturer.

Mode of power-frequency regulation (MRPF)

This simulation makes it possible to evaluate the dynamic response of the wind farm to slight variations in the grid frequency. To do this, a frequency sweep is carried out between 49.7 Hz and 50.3 Hz and it is checked that the power variations of the wind farm and the stabilisation time comply with the ranges indicated in the standard.

The following figure shows the simulation results for the overfrequency case, which comply with the requirements of the standard, both in terms of power variation and stabilisation time.

Fig 3. Complementary simulation of the power-frequency control mode (soffrequency)

Reactive power capability requirement

This static simulation makes it possible to evaluate the generation and reactive power absorption capacity of the wind farm both at its maximum power (Fig 4 left) and at power levels below the maximum (Fig 4 right).

Fig 4. Complementary simulation of the reactive power capacity requirement

In Fig 4 we can see the compliance with the requirement as the capacity curve of the wind farm (dashed line) is outside the curve required in the NTS. If you are interested in knowing more about this simulation you can read about it in a previous post on the Norvento blog.

Reactive power control requirement

The reactive power control simulations make it possible to evaluate the dynamic reactive power response of the wind farm to variations in the reactive power setpoint, the power factor setpoint or the wind farm input voltage. To do this, it is necessary to simulate the three reactive power control modes separately:

  • Reactive power control mode
  • Power factor control mode
  • Voltage control mode

The following figure shows the results obtained in the simulation of the reactive power control mode, where it can be seen how the wind farm reaches the required reactive power setpoints in times lower than those required by the standard.

Fig 5. Complementary simulation of the reactive power control mode

What documentation do I have to submit to certify compliance with the technical requirements?

In order to certify compliance with the technical requirements mentioned above, the reports of the complementary simulations, in addition to the certificates of the plant equipment, must be submitted to an authorised certifier. Once compliance with all applicable requirements has been verified, the authorised certifier will issue the final plant certificate, which certifies compliance with the grid codes.

Desde Norvento ayudamos a nuestros clientes a certificar el cumplimiento de los códigos de red, requisito indispensable para la entrada en operación comercial de una planta de generación.

Ignacio de Lis Aguirregomezcorta

Ignacio holds a degree in Industrial Engineering from the Polytechnic University of Madrid and is part of Norvento’s Grid Studies Department, where he develops grid study projects for the connection of renewable generation plants. Contact with Ignacio

Share: Facebook Mail Linkedin Twitter
< Regulation for integration Demand management >
  • Energy
    • Wind Power
    • Hydroelectric
  • Self-Consumption
    • Wind
    • Photovoltaic Solar
    • Storage
    • Microgrids
    • Biogas
    • Hydrogen
  • TECHnPower
    • Wind turbines
      • nED100
    • Energy Storage
      • Battery Energy Storage Systems
      • Power converters
  • Services
    • Decarbonization
    • Energy Engineering
    • EPC Energy
    • Operation & Maintenance
    • 24/7 Control Centre
    • Monitoring & Control
  • Norvento
    • Get to know us better
    • Our team
    • Sustainability
    • Innovation
  • Work with us
    • Your career at Norvento
    • Talent Scholarship Scheme
  • Communication
    • Press room
    • Blog
  • Contact us
  • Visit us
  • CIne, our headquarters. Zero Energy Building
  • Linkedin
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • © 2025
  • R&D Projects
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Whistleblower Channel
En
  • Es
  • Gl
  • Energy
    • Wind Power
    • Hydroelectric
  • Self-Consumption
    • Wind
    • Photovoltaic Solar
    • Storage
    • Microgrids
    • Biogas
    • Hydrogen
  • TECHnPower
    • Wind turbines
      • nED100
    • Energy Storage
      • Battery Energy Storage Systems
      • Power converters
  • Services
    • Decarbonization
    • Energy Engineering
    • EPC Energy
    • Operation & Maintenance
    • 24/7 Control Centre
    • Monitoring & Control
  • Norvento
    • Get to know us better
    • Our team
    • Sustainability
    • Innovation
  • Work with us
    • Your career at Norvento
    • Talent Scholarship Scheme
  • Communication
    • Press room
    • Blog
  • Contact us
  • Visit us
  • CIne, our headquarters. Zero Energy Building
Gestionar consentimiento

At Norvento Enerxía we use our own and third-party cookies for different purposes: performance, security and analytics. You can customize your preferences through the configuration panel, as well as obtain additional information about the processing of your data, including the exercise of your rights, by consulting our Cookies Policy.
You can change the settings at any time by returning to the dashboard, clicking on a different option, and refreshing the web page. 

Technicals Always active
Analítica
Preferencias
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico es necesario para la finalidad legítima de almacenar preferencias no solicitadas por el abonado o usuario.
Statistics
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico que es utilizado exclusivamente con fines estadísticos. El almacenamiento o acceso técnico que se utiliza exclusivamente con fines estadísticos anónimos. Sin un requerimiento, el cumplimiento voluntario por parte de tu proveedor de servicios de Internet, o los registros adicionales de un tercero, la información almacenada o recuperada sólo para este propósito no se puede utilizar para identificarte.
Marketing
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico es necesario para crear perfiles de usuario para enviar publicidad, o para rastrear al usuario en una web o en varias web con fines de marketing similares.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Set my preferences
{title} {title} {title}